Quick Summary
When installing hardwood floors, choose the right fasteners to avoid damage and ensure a secure fit. For solid hardwood, use a flooring nailer with L-shaped cleat nails (1.5” to 2” long, 16-gauge). Engineered hardwood often uses staples or smaller cleat nails. Always consult your flooring manufacturer’s recommendations.

Table of Contents

What Nails To Use For Hardwood Flooring: An Essential Guide

Planning to install a beautiful hardwood floor? That’s fantastic! It’s a project that adds immense value and charm to any home. But before you start laying down those gorgeous planks, there’s a crucial question that needs a clear answer: what nails should you use for hardwood flooring? Choosing the wrong fasteners can lead to cupping, splitting, or even a wobbly floor in no time. Don’t worry, I’m here to help! As Nailerguy, I’ve seen it all, and I’ll guide you through selecting the perfect nails so your DIY project turns out as smooth and solid as the floor itself. We’ll cover everything from the types of nails to the best tools to use. Let’s get your floor installed right from the start!

Understanding Your Hardwood: Solid vs. Engineered

Before we dive into nail specifics, it’s super important to know what kind of hardwood flooring you’re working with. This makes a big difference in how you’ll fasten it down.

Solid Hardwood Flooring:

These planks are milled from a single piece of genuine hardwood.
They are typically ¾ inch thick.
Solid hardwood can expand and contract significantly with changes in humidity and temperature.
Because of this, it’s almost always glued and nailed down to a subfloor.

Engineered Hardwood Flooring:

This type has a thin top layer of real hardwood veneer over several layers of plywood or high-density fiberboard.
It’s more stable than solid hardwood and less prone to expanding and contracting.
Engineered hardwood can be installed in many ways: glued down, floated (using an interlocking system), or sometimes nailed down, especially thicker ¾-inch varieties.
Check your specific product details!

The Power of the Flooring Nailer

When it comes to installing hardwood flooring, trust me, a good flooring nailer is your best friend. These specialized tools are designed to drive nails at a precise angle to grip the tongue of the floorboard and secure it to the subfloor without damaging the wood’s surface.

Why use a flooring nailer?

Efficiency: They are much faster than hand-nailing.
Precision: They drive nails at the correct angle every time, ensuring a strong hold without breaking through the wood.
Protection: They typically have a protective shoe that guards the flooring surface from accidental dings.

There are two main types of flooring nailers:

Cleat Nailers: These use L-shaped metal fasteners called “cleats.” They are the standard and most recommended for solid hardwood.
Staple Nailers: These use T-shaped staples. They are sometimes recommended for thinner engineered hardwood, but cleats are generally preferred for their holding power.

For most DIYers tackling solid hardwood, a pneumatic cleat flooring nailer is the way to go. You can rent them if you don’t want to buy one for a single project. Make sure you pair it with the right compressor!

Choosing the Right Nails (Cleats) for Solid Hardwood

This is where we get down to the nitty-gritty of what nails to use for hardwood flooring. For solid hardwood, you’ll be using cleats driven by a flooring nailer.

Cleat Nails are specifically designed for hardwood flooring. They are narrow and have a small barb or rough texture to help them grip the wood securely. They are typically L-shaped, which allows the nailer to drive them through the tongue of the floorboard at a 30-45 degree angle into the subfloor.

Here’s what to look for:

Length: The most common length for solid hardwood ¾-inch planks is 1.5 inches to 2 inches. The nail needs to be long enough to go through the flooring material, at least half the thickness of the subfloor. For example, a 1.5” nail might be ideal for a ¾” plank over a ½” or 5/8” plywood subfloor, allowing about 3/4” of the nail to embed into the subfloor. Always check your flooring manufacturer’s recommendations AND your subfloor thickness.
Gauge: The most common gauge for flooring cleats is 16-gauge. Sometimes 18-gauge might be used for very thin engineered wood, but 16-gauge cleats offer superior holding power for solid hardwood.
Material: Cleats are usually made of steel.
Coating: Some cleats have a coating to help them drive more easily and reduce the risk of rust.

Why Cleats are King for Solid Hardwood

Cleats are the preferred fastener for solid hardwood flooring for several key reasons:

Superior Holding Power: Their shape and texture are designed to prevent the wood from loosening over time. As the wood expands and contracts, the cleat’s grip helps resist squeaks and movement.
Minimal Surface Damage: They are driven through the tongue of the board, meaning they are completely hidden once the floor is installed.
Durability: They create a strong, lasting bond between the flooring and the subfloor, which is crucial for solid wood that experiences more movement than engineered wood.

Nails for Engineered Hardwood: A Slightly Different Story

Engineered hardwood is a bit more forgiving, but it’s crucial to follow the manufacturer’s installation guide.

Staples:

Some engineered hardwood floors, especially those that are thinner (e.g., 3/8 inch), can be installed using crown staples.
These are driven by a specialized staple gun, often called a T-nailer or staple cleat nailer.
The staples have a wider crown to distribute pressure across the tongue and groove without damaging the thinner wood.
Make sure you use staples specifically designed for flooring.

Cleats:

Thicker engineered hardwood (e.g., ¾ inch) can often be installed with the same cleat nails and flooring nailer used for solid hardwood.
Again, always consult your specific product’s installation instructions. Some manufacturers allow for glue-down or floating installation, which may not require any nails at all.

Important Note on Glue-Down/Floating Floors:

Many engineered floors are designed to be glued directly to the subfloor or to be “floated” using a click-lock system. In these cases, nails or staples are not part of the installation process. Confirming your floor type is step one!

Other Fastener Considerations & What NOT to Use

You might be tempted to use other types of nails, but trust me, it’s best to stick to what’s designed for the job.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Using Common Drywall Screws or Finish Nails: These are absolutely not suitable for flooring. Drywall screws are brittle and can snap. Finish nails are too short and won’t provide enough holding power, and they can also split the wood.
Using the Wrong Gauge Nailer/Nails: A nailer that’s too powerful or uses an incorrect gauge can break the tongue of the flooring or drive the nail improperly, leading to damage.
Nailing into Joists Only: While you need to hit joists for a solid wood floor, you also need to nail into the recommended subfloor material for full support. Modern flooring installation relies on a solid subfloor layer as well.

Alternative Fasteners for Specific Situations

Polymer or Composite Nails:

Some newer flooring systems might incorporate specialized fasteners or adhesives. Always follow the product manufacturer’s recommendations explicitly. For example, some manufacturers offer specific adhesive systems rather than expecting nails.

Adhesives:

As mentioned, many engineered floors and some solid wood floors (especially in certain humidity-prone regions) are installed using a combination of adhesive and fasteners, or solely with adhesive. This can offer excellent stability and reduce noise.

Nail Size Chart: A Quick Reference

To help you visualize, here’s a quick guide. Remember, these are general recommendations, and you should always defer to your specific flooring manufacturer’s installation guide.

Flooring Type	Nail/Fastener Type	Gauge	Length	Best For
Solid Hardwood (¾” thick)	L-Cleat Nails	16-gauge	1.5″ – 2″	Primary fastener for secure, long-lasting installation.
Engineered Hardwood (Thicker, > ½”)	L-Cleat Nails	16-gauge	1.5″ – 2″	When manufacturer allows nailing; provides strong hold.
Engineered Hardwood (Thinner, < ½")	Crown Staples	Not Applicable (Staple Crown Width Matters)	1″ – 1.5″	When manufacturer approves staples; check compatibility with staple gun.
Engineered Hardwood (Specific Systems)	Manufacturer-Specific Fasteners/Adhesives	N/A	N/A	Follow manufacturer’s installation guide precisely.

Important Note on Subfloor:

The type and thickness of your subfloor (plywood, OSB, or concrete) are critical factors in choosing fastener length and type. Always ensure your subfloor is properly prepared and meets minimum thickness requirements, typically ½ inch.

Preparing Your Subfloor: The Foundation of Success

Even with the perfect nails, your floor won’t last if the foundation isn’t right. A well-prepared subfloor is essential for a stable, squeak-free, and durable hardwood floor.

Here’s a quick checklist for subfloor prep:

Cleanliness: Ensure the subfloor is free from dust, debris, paint, wax, or any other contaminants.
Flatness: The subfloor must be perfectly flat. Use a straightedge to check for high spots (which can be sanded down) and low spots (which may need leveling compound). An uneven subfloor can cause undue stress on your flooring and fasteners.
Dryness: Moisture is the enemy of hardwood. Ensure the subfloor is completely dry. You can use a moisture meter for accurate readings, especially over concrete slabs. For concrete, a moisture barrier is often required.
Soundness: The subfloor should be solid and not have any loose or squeaky boards. Any issues here should be fixed before you start laying new flooring.
Underlayment/Moisture Barrier: Depending on your subfloor type and the flooring manufacturer’s recommendations, you may need to install a moisture barrier (like felt paper or a plastic sheeting) and/or a thin underlayment for sound dampening or slight cushioning. Always check if your chosen underlayment is compatible with your specific nailing system. Some manufacturers of flooring nailers and cleats recommend specific underlayments for optimal performance. For example, some wood flooring manufacturers recommend a specific type of felt paper as recommended by national standards. You can find more details on subfloor preparation and underlayment requirements from organizations like the National Wood Flooring Association (NWFA).

A professionally prepared subfloor is often the difference between a floor you love and one that becomes a constant source of frustration.

FAQ: Your Flooring Nail Questions Answered

Q1: Can I use a regular finish nailer for hardwood floors?

A1: No, it’s highly recommended not to. Regular finish nailers use slim, straight nails that don’t have the holding power or the correct angle needed for hardwood. Flooring nailers and cleat nails are specifically designed for this job to prevent damage and ensure a secure bond.

Q2: What is the difference between a cleat nail and a staple for flooring?

A2: Cleat nails are L-shaped and driven at an angle into the tongue of the wood, providing superior holding power. Staples are T-shaped and are sometimes used for thinner engineered wood, but they can potentially damage the wood if not used with the correct setup.

Q3: How long should my flooring nails be?

A3: For standard ¾-inch solid hardwood, 1.5-inch to 2-inch cleat nails are typical. The key is that the nail must penetrate the subfloor by at least half its thickness to ensure a firm hold. Always check your flooring and subfloor thickness.

Q4: Do I need a special nail gun for hardwood flooring?

A4: Yes. You’ll need a flooring nailer (either a cleat nailer or a staple nailer, depending on your flooring type and manufacturer’s recommendation). These are specialized tools that drive fasteners at the correct angle for optimal grip and minimal surface damage.

Q5: What if my flooring manufacturer recommends glue-down installation?

A5: If your manufacturer recommends a glue-down or floating installation, follow their instructions precisely. In these cases, you will not use nails or staples. Adhesives designed for hardwood flooring provide a strong hold and can also help with sound reduction and moisture resistance.

Q6: Can I use screws to install hardwood floors?

A6: While screws offer a strong hold, they are generally not recommended for the visible installation of hardwood flooring. They can split the wood, and countersinking them sufficiently to hide them without damaging the board surface is difficult. Flooring nailers are the industry standard for a reason.

Q7: What is the best subfloor for hardwood flooring?

A7: Plywood is generally considered the best subfloor material for hardwood flooring because it offers excellent stability and is receptive to nailing. ¾-inch thick tongue-and-groove plywood is ideal. OSB (Oriented Strand Board) can also be used, but it’s typically slightly less stable and requires strict adherence to moisture content guidelines. Concrete subfloors require a specific moisture barrier and often a layer of plywood over them before installing hardwood.

For more detailed guidance on subflooring, you can refer to resources like Fine Homebuilding’s guide, which offers practical insights for DIYers.

Conclusion: Nail It Right for a Floor That Lasts

So, there you have it! Choosing what nails to use for hardwood flooring really comes down to understanding your specific flooring material and following the manufacturer’s guidance. For solid hardwood, 16-gauge L-cleat nails in the 1.5” to 2” range, driven by a quality flooring nailer, are your go-to. For engineered wood, always check the specs – it might be staples or cleats, or perhaps no nails at all if it’s a glue-down or floating system.

Remember, the right fastener isn’t just about holding the wood down; it’s about ensuring your beautiful new floor stays put, looks fantastic, and lasts for generations. Don’t cut corners here – equip yourself with the right tools and fasteners, prepare your subfloor diligently, and you’ll be rewarded with a stunning, durable hardwood floor that you can be incredibly proud of. Happy flooring!